Evicting a brother from inherited property requires understanding his legal status as either a beneficiary with occupation rights, an excluded occupier without formal protection, or a trespasser – with executors holding absolute authority to remove unauthorised occupants during probate administration, though court proceedings may be necessary if he refuses voluntary departure.
British inheritance disputes have reached unprecedented levels, with legal experts reporting a 47% increase in sibling property conflicts over the past three years. Recent court data shows that 122 contested probate cases reached the High Court in 2023, whilst an estimated 10,000 people across England and Wales dispute wills annually. With the average British inheritance now valued at £195,687 – of which £182,621 comes from property assets – and 43% of Brits counting on inherited property for their financial security, these family conflicts have become increasingly common and financially devastating for families involved.
Table of Contents
How to evict brother from inherited property?
Your authority to remove your brother depends entirely on his legal status and your role in the estate administration. During probate, executors possess complete control over who can occupy estate property, regardless of family relationships or emotional attachments to the family home.
If you’re an executor, you can change locks, demand he leaves immediately, or apply for court orders without requiring consent from other beneficiaries. This executive power exists because the estate legally owns the property until probate completes and transfers ownership to inheritors.
However, if your brother is a joint beneficiary with equal inheritance rights, the situation becomes more complex once probate finishes. Joint owners cannot exclude each other from the property, though they can seek occupation rent for exclusive use or apply for court-ordered sales.
Can You Legally Evict a Sibling From Inherited Property?
Yes, you can legally evict a sibling from inherited property, but the process depends on whether they have legitimate occupation rights or are considered trespassers. Executors can remove siblings without formal tenancy agreements by serving notice to quit and pursuing possession proceedings if they refuse to leave voluntarily.
The legal framework treats siblings differently based on their status. Beneficiaries who inherit joint ownership cannot be evicted like tenants, but they can be forced to sell through court applications under the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996.
Family members living there without inheritance rights or formal agreements are considered excluded occupiers or trespassers, making removal procedures more straightforward through standard possession claims.
What Notice Period Must You Give Before Evicting Your Brother?
The required notice period depends on your brother’s legal classification and local circumstances. Excluded occupiers without tenancy agreements can be given as little as reasonable notice – often 28 days – before court proceedings begin.
If your brother has lived there for extended periods whilst contributing to household expenses, he might claim implied tenancy rights that require longer notice periods. However, family members who simply remained after parents’ deaths without paying rent rarely gain formal tenant protection.
Executors should provide written notice specifying departure dates and consequences of non-compliance. This documentation becomes essential evidence if court proceedings become necessary.
Different Legal Classifications for Brothers in Inherited Property
Understanding your brother’s legal status determines the appropriate removal procedure and likely success rates for eviction applications.
| Legal Status | Notice Required | Eviction Difficulty | Court Success Rate | Timeframe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Joint Beneficiary | Cannot evict directly | High – requires sale order | Moderate | 6-12 months |
| Excluded Occupier | 28 days reasonable notice | Low | High | 2-4 months |
| Trespasser | Immediate | Very Low | Very High | 1-2 months |
| Implied Tenant | 2 months minimum | Moderate | Moderate | 3-6 months |
This classification system helps determine realistic expectations for removal timelines and legal costs. Joint beneficiaries present the greatest challenges, whilst trespassers can be removed relatively quickly
Steps to Remove Your Brother From Inherited Property
Determine his legal status and any occupation rights granted in the will
Serve formal written notice specifying departure dates and legal consequences
Document all communications and his responses to removal requests
Apply for possession orders if he refuses to leave voluntarily
Prepare evidence of your authority as executor or majority beneficiary
Attend court hearings with legal representation if contested
Arrange bailiff enforcement if court grants possession orders
Following these steps in sequence protects your legal position whilst demonstrating reasonable attempts at voluntary resolution. Courts favour applicants who show they’ve tried negotiation before pursuing formal proceedings.
Reddit Insights: Real Experiences of Sibling Property Evictions
Property Saviour has observed patterns in online discussions about sibling evictions that reveal common challenges families face. One Reddit user described how their brother delayed court proceedings for eight months by claiming he had nowhere else to live, despite the family home being worth over £1.1 million.
Another family discovered that charging occupation rent created unexpected complications when their brother argued this established a landlord-tenant relationship that strengthened his position. Property Saviour recommends avoiding informal rental arrangements that might complicate future eviction proceedings.
Multiple Reddit discussions highlight how siblings often use delaying tactics, claiming verbal promises from deceased parents or threatening counter-claims against the estate. These strategies rarely succeed legally but can extend proceedings significantly and increase emotional stress for families.
How to Handle Brothers Who Claim Verbal Promises From Deceased Parents?
Brothers who refuse to leave often claim the deceased promised them the family home or lifetime occupation rights. These verbal assurances rarely hold legal weight unless supported by written evidence or actions that demonstrate clear intentions.
Courts recognise proprietary estoppel claims when someone relied on promises to their detriment, such as contributing significantly to property improvements or forgoing other opportunities. However, simply living in the family home without paying rent doesn’t establish these legal rights.
Document any contributions your brother made to the property and whether these were gifts or investments expecting returns. Professional legal advice becomes essential when brothers claim substantial improvements or financial contributions that might affect their entitlements.
Real-Life Example: James’s Dilemma in Chester
James contacted Property Saviour after inheriting his father’s house in Chester with his two sisters, but his brother refused to leave despite being served formal notice six months earlier. The brother claimed their father promised him the house verbally, though nothing appeared in the will.
“We were emotionally drained by the constant arguments and legal threats,” James explained. “My brother made viewing appointments impossible and prospective buyers were put off by the hostile atmosphere he created.”
Rather than endure years of court proceedings that would damage family relationships permanently, James and his sisters chose Property Saviour’s guaranteed purchase service. This decision provided immediate access to their inheritance whilst avoiding the stress and uncertainty of forced eviction proceedings.
When family disputes make traditional sales impossible and legal proceedings seem overwhelming, Property Saviour offers compassionate solutions that respect everyone’s dignity whilst ensuring you receive fair value for your inheritance without prolonged conflict.
Court Procedures for Forcing Sale When Brothers Refuse to Leave
When negotiation fails and your brother refuses voluntary departure, courts can order property sales under Section 14 of the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996. These applications require evidence that continued occupation prevents proper estate administration or unfairly disadvantages other beneficiaries.
Courts consider multiple factors before granting sale orders, including the deceased’s intentions, current property use, welfare of any children living there, and interests of secured creditors. Applications succeed more often when executors demonstrate they’ve attempted reasonable compromises.
Legal costs for forced sale applications can exceed £15,000, with unsuccessful applicants potentially liable for opponents’ expenses. Many families discover that sell inherited house through specialist buyers like Property Saviour provides better financial outcomes than lengthy court battles.
Occupation Rent Claims Against Brothers Living Rent-Free
When brothers live exclusively in jointly inherited property, other beneficiaries can claim occupation rent reflecting their proportional ownership shares. This ensures fair treatment when one person enjoys valuable free accommodation whilst others receive nothing from their inheritance.
Occupation rent calculations use current market rental values adjusted for the occupying brother’s ownership percentage. Courts can order these payments retrospectively and ongoing, though enforcement often proves challenging when brothers lack sufficient income.
Successful occupation rent claims require evidence of market rental values, clear ownership percentages, and proof that exclusive occupation disadvantages other beneficiaries. However, legal costs often exceed potential recovery amounts, making negotiated settlements more practical than court enforcement.
Alternative Solutions When Brothers Won’t Leave Inherited Property
Before pursuing expensive legal proceedings, consider whether alternative arrangements might satisfy everyone’s needs whilst preserving family relationships. Buy-out agreements allow brothers to purchase other siblings’ shares at fair market value, giving them security whilst providing others with immediate inheritance access.
Delayed sale agreements with specific timelines can provide brothers with housing security whilst guaranteeing eventual property disposition. Professional mediation often achieves creative solutions that court proceedings cannot deliver.
When these alternatives fail and family relationships deteriorate beyond repair, Property Saviour’s guaranteed purchase service removes the emotional burden from inheritance disputes whilst ensuring fair financial outcomes for all parties involved.
We Buy Any House: Property Saviour’s Solution for Inheritance Disputes
When family inheritance disputes become overwhelming or when you need certainty and speed in resolving property inheritance challenges, Property Saviour offers a compassionate alternative to lengthy legal battles. Our guaranteed purchase service eliminates the complexities of multiple beneficiary negotiations, executor disagreements, and family relationship strain that often accompanies inherited property situations.
Unlike traditional sales that can take months and may fall through due to financing issues, Property Saviour provides firm cash offers with guaranteed completion dates. This certainty proves invaluable when inheritance tax deadlines approach or when family relationships face strain from prolonged property disputes. Our service recognises that inheritance situations often involve emotional complexities alongside financial considerations, providing the understanding and flexibility that challenging family circumstances require.
Living in an inherited house as a beneficiary involves complex legal, financial, and emotional considerations that vary significantly based on individual circumstances. Understanding your rights, the executors’ powers, and potential resolution options helps you make informed decisions about your future whilst preserving family relationships during difficult times.
Sell with certainty & speed
Property Saviour Price Promise
- The price we’ll offer is the price that you will receive with no hidden deductions.
- Be careful with ‘cash buyers’ who require a valuation needed for a mortgage or bridging loan.
- These valuations or surveys result in delays and price reductions later on.
- We are cash buyers. There are no surveys.
- We always provide proof of funds with every formal offer issued.
We'll Pay £1,500 Towards Your Legal Fees
- No long exclusivity agreement to sign because we are the buyers.
- You are welcome to use your own solicitor.
- If you don’t have one, we can ask our solicitors for recommendations.
- We share our solicitor’s details and issue a Memorandum of Sale.
Sell With Certainty & Speed
- Our approach is transparent and ethical, which is why sellers trust us.
- 100% Discretion guaranteed.
- If you have another buyer, you can put us in a contracts race to see who completes first.
- Complete in 10 days or at a timescale that works for you. You are in control.
