Imagine falling head over heels for your dream home, only to discover you can’t build that garden office or keep your beloved family dog because of some mysterious rules buried in the paperwork. Frustrating, isn’t it? That’s the reality for many homeowners who encounter covenants and easements after purchasing their property.
In the UK, approximately 78% of freehold properties have some form of restrictive covenant attached to them, according to recent Land Registry data. Even more concerning, over 40% of homeowners are completely unaware of these restrictions until they try to make changes to their property. Understanding these legal constraints before you buy could save you thousands of pounds and countless headaches.
Table of Contents
What Is A Restrictive Covenant?
A restrictive covenant is a binding legal promise attached to your property that limits how you can use or develop it. Think of it as an invisible fence around what you can and cannot do with your home. Unlike planning permission which comes from local authorities, these restrictions are typically created by previous landowners or developers and remain with the property regardless of how many times it changes hands.
“Most people assume that owning their home freehold means they can do whatever they like with it,” explains property expert Ramnik from Property Saviour. “The reality is that many properties come with strings attached that can limit everything from the colour you paint your front door to whether you can run a small business from home.”
These restrictions serve a purpose – usually to maintain a neighbourhood’s character, preserve property values, or protect the interests of surrounding homeowners. But they can feel incredibly restrictive when they prevent you from making your house truly feel like home.
Restrictive Covenants Example: Common Limitations You Might Face
If you’re wondering what these restrictions actually look like in practice, here are some typical examples we’ve encountered while helping homeowners across Yorkshire:
No building extensions or additional structures without permission
Prohibition on running businesses from the property
Restrictions on keeping certain pets or livestock
Requirements to maintain particular aesthetic features
Limitations on parking commercial vehicles at the property
Restrictions on installing satellite dishes or solar panels
Prohibition on subdividing the property into multiple dwellings
One Bristol family we assisted discovered they couldn’t build a modest home office in their garden because a covenant dating back to 1963 prevented any “additional structures” being erected. This seemingly minor restriction was threatening to derail their plans for remote working – until we helped them sell their property by negotiating with the covenant beneficiary.
How to remove a covenant?
Removing a restrictive covenant from your property can be achieved through two main routes: negotiating directly with whoever benefits from the covenant or applying to the Upper Tribunal if they won’t cooperate. The negotiation route often proves more straightforward and cost-effective, especially when you can offer reasonable compensation in exchange for a formal deed of release.
If negotiation fails, the Upper Tribunal can discharge or modify covenants that are obsolete, prevent reasonable use of your property, or provide no practical benefit to anyone. This legal route takes longer and costs more – typically £3,000-£10,000 including legal representation – but offers a definitive solution when other options are exhausted.
For many property owners, indemnity insurance provides a practical alternative to formal removal. This covers you against future enforcement claims without the time and expense of actually removing the covenant. It’s particularly useful when selling, as it reassures buyers and mortgage lenders while costing just a few hundred pounds.
Can I Ignore A Restrictive Covenant?
It’s tempting to think, “What’s the worst that could happen if I just go ahead anyway?” – particularly if the covenant seems ancient or unreasonable. However, ignoring restrictive covenants can lead to serious consequences that might cost far more than complying would have done initially.
If you breach a covenant, the beneficiary (often neighbours or developers) can take legal action against you. This might result in:
An injunction forcing you to undo the work (imagine demolishing that extension you’ve just spent £50,000 building)
Financial compensation for any reduction in neighbouring property values
Legal costs that can quickly spiral into thousands of pounds
We recently helped a homeowner in Derby who had innocently converted their garage into a home office, unaware of a covenant preventing changes to the building’s external appearance. Their neighbour had threatened legal action that could have cost them over £20,000 in legal fees and remediation work. Thankfully, we were able to buy the property and then negotiate a compensation before the situation escalated to court.
The Subtle But Crucial Difference Between Positive and Negative Covenants
When reveiwing property restrictions, understanding the subtle but crucial distinction between different types of promises can save you significant headaches:
| Type | Description | Enforceability | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Negative Covenants | Prohibit certain actions | Generally bind future owners | No building extensions, no business use |
| Positive Covenants | Require specific actions | May not bind future owners | Maintain shared driveway, paint exterior regularly |
| Easements | Grant rights to use land | Bind future owners | Right of way, access for utilities |
| Equitable Servitudes | Similar to covenants but enforced through injunction | Bind future owners with notice | Restrictions on property use |
This table highlights why it’s essential to understand exactly what type of restriction affects your property. The way these different obligations are enforced varies significantly, which could be the difference between a minor inconvenience and a major legal battle.
Can A Neighbour Enforce A Restrictive Covenant?
Yes, your neighbour can potentially enforce a restrictive covenant, but only if they have what’s called “the benefit” of the covenant. This typically means they own land that was part of the original estate when the covenant was created, or the covenant was specifically created to benefit their property.
If your neighbour believes you’re breaching a covenant that benefits them, they might take several steps:
Send you a friendly (or not-so-friendly) letter highlighting the issue
Provide formal notice requesting you stop the breach
Seek legal advice and potentially threaten court action
Apply for an injunction or damages through the courts
We helped Mrs. Thompson in Warwick when her neighbour threatened legal action over a small home business she was running. The covenant prohibited “commercial activities,” but we successfully argued that her occasional crafting workshops fell below the threshold of commercial use that would diminish neighbourhood character or property values.
Do Restrictive Covenants Stand Up In Court?
The courts generally do uphold valid restrictive covenants, especially when they’re clearly written and continue to serve a genuine purpose. However, there are several grounds upon which covenants can be challenged or deemed unenforceable:
The covenant is ambiguous or poorly drafted
The character of the neighbourhood has changed significantly
The covenant is obsolete or no longer serves its original purpose
The person trying to enforce it doesn’t actually have the benefit of the covenant
The breach has continued unchallenged for a significant period
“Don’t assume a covenant is unenforceable just because it seems old or unreasonable,” warns Saddat, our property specialist. “We’ve seen cases where restrictions from the 1950s have been successfully enforced because they still serve a legitimate purpose in preserving neighbourhood character.”
What Is The 12 Year Rule For Restrictive Covenant?
The 12 year rule refers to the limitation period set out in the Limitation Act 1980, which states that legal action must be taken within 12 years of a breach of a restrictive covenant occurring. This doesn’t mean the covenant expires after 12 years – it means that if someone has been breaching a covenant for more than 12 years without challenge, it becomes more difficult for the beneficiary to take legal action regarding that specific breach.
“It’s crucial to understand that this time limit starts from when the breach began, not from when the covenant was created,” explains Saddat. “A covenant from 1970 is still fully enforceable today if you’ve only just started breaching it.”
This rule offers some protection if you’ve been openly breaching a covenant for over 12 years without complaint. However, relying on this defence is risky without professional advice, as the courts apply strict criteria when considering whether the limitation period has truly expired.
How do I remove a restrictive covenant from my property?
Removing a restrictive covenant isn’t straightforward, but you do have options. First, try negotiating directly with whoever benefits from the covenant – they might agree to release it for a fee.
If that’s impossible or unsuccessful, you can apply to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) to modify or discharge the covenant under certain grounds: if it’s obsolete, if it impedes reasonable land use, if everyone who benefits agrees, or if no harm would result from removing it.
This process typically costs between £3,000-£10,000 and takes 6-12 months.
Alternatively, you could consider indemnity insurance to protect against the risk of someone enforcing the covenant – this is often the quickest solution when selling a property with a breach.
Before taking any action, get professional legal advice specific to your situation, as the wrong approach could waste time and money or even alert beneficiaries who might otherwise have remained unaware of the breach.
Can I build an extension if there’s a restrictive covenant?
Yes, you might still be able to build your extension despite a restrictive covenant, but proceed with caution! First, check exactly what the covenant prohibits – some only restrict specific types of extensions or require approval rather than banning them outright. If the covenant clearly prevents your plans, consider approaching the beneficiary (usually a neighbour, developer or management company) to seek permission – they might agree if your plans are reasonable and won’t affect them negatively.
If direct negotiation fails, you could apply to the Upper Tribunal to modify the covenant, but this can be expensive and time-consuming with no guarantee of success. Alternatively, some homeowners opt for indemnity insurance to protect against future enforcement, though this doesn’t make the breach legal.
Whatever you decide, don’t simply ignore the covenant – we’ve seen heart breaking cases where homeowners have had to demolish expensive extensions after neighbours successfully enforced long-forgotten restrictions. Always get professional legal advice before spending any money on plans or construction.
How long do restrictive covenants last?
Restrictive covenants don’t have a built-in expiry date – they can theoretically last forever unless specifically removed! This surprises many homeowners who discover centuries-old restrictions still affecting their modern properties. While some people believe covenants automatically expire after 80 years (due to confusion with certain planning rules), this simply isn’t true for most property restrictions.
The covenant’s age can, however, help you challenge it. Very old covenants may be considered “obsolete” if the original purpose no longer exists – for example, a 1920s covenant preventing “the keeping of pigs” might be obsolete in a now-urban area. Similarly, if an area’s character has completely changed, or the restriction has been widely ignored without enforcement, you might have grounds to have it declared unenforceable.
Remember though, even Victorian-era covenants can remain legally valid if they still serve a genuine purpose! If you’re concerned about an ancient covenant affecting your property, seek specialist advice rather than assuming time has rendered it powerless – many homeowners have learned this lesson the hard way after costly legal battles.
Trapped by Restrictive Covenants? We’ll Buy Your Problem Property
Feeling stuck with a property that has restrictive covenants making it impossible to sell or develop? You’re not alone. Those frustrating legal constraints can turn your dream home into a nightmare – but there’s a way out.
At Property Saviour, we don’t just understand restrictive covenants – we specialise in solving the very problems they create. While solicitors might throw their hands up or recommend costly court battles, we see opportunity where others see only obstacles.
We Buy Properties That Others Won’t Touch
We recently helped a Northampton family who discovered they couldn’t extend their home because of a 1960s covenant. Their sale had fallen through twice, until we stepped in.
We purchase all types of properties with covenant complications:
Land with development restrictions
Properties with covenant breaches
Homes with defective leases
Houses where the covenant beneficiary has disappeared
Don’t let these invisible legal handcuffs hold you prisoner in your own home. Where lawyers see complexities, we see solutions – and we back that up with ready cash to purchase your problematic property.
A Straightforward Solution When You Need It Most
The process couldn’t be simpler. We’ll make you a fair cash offer, work around your timeframe, and even cover your legal fees. No estate agent commissions, no viewings with nosy neighbours, and absolutely no judgment about any covenant breaches.
Can a neighbour enforce a restrictive covenant? Absolutely – and many do, leaving homeowners in expensive legal battles. We’ve helped numerous property owners escape exactly this situation before it escalates to court.
“Property Saviour was my lifeline when I discovered my garden office breached a covenant I knew nothing about,” explains Michael from Newcastle. “They offered a fair price and handled everything, even with my neighbour threatening legal action.”
Get Your Free, No-Obligation Offer Today
Why struggle with what is a restrictive covenant problem when there’s a simple solution? Contact us today for a confidential chat about your situation. We promise:
A fair cash offer within 24 hours
Quick completion on your timeline
No fees – we even pay your legal costs
No stress or complicated negotiations
Don’t let outdated restrictions determine your future. Discover how we can transform your property challenge into a fresh start. Where solicitors see dead ends, Property Saviour sees the opportunity to live up to our name.
Sell with certainty & speed
Property Saviour Price Promise
- The price we’ll offer is the price that you will receive with no hidden deductions.
- Be careful with ‘cash buyers’ who require a valuation needed for a mortgage or bridging loan.
- These valuations or surveys result in delays and price reductions later on.
- We are cash buyers. There are no surveys.
- We always provide proof of funds with every formal offer issued.
We'll Pay £1,500 Towards Your Legal Fees
- No long exclusivity agreement to sign because we are the buyers.
- You are welcome to use your own solicitor.
- If you don’t have one, we can ask our solicitors for recommendations.
- We share our solicitor’s details and issue a Memorandum of Sale.
Sell With Certainty & Speed
- Our approach is transparent and ethical, which is why sellers trust us.
- 100% Discretion guaranteed.
- If you have another buyer, you can put us in a contracts race to see who completes first.
- Complete in 10 days or at a timescale that works for you. You are in control.
