Contesting a will succeeds in only 3-5% of cases that reach court annually in England and Wales, though success rates vary dramatically based on the grounds for challenge, strength of evidence, and whether cases settle out of court – with approximately half of all will disputes resolving through negotiation rather than formal litigation.
The statistics surrounding will contests paint a stark picture of both increasing disputes and challenging success rates. Ministry of Justice data shows inheritance disputes rose from 145 court cases in 2017 to 195 in 2023, representing a 34% increase in just six years. Industry experts estimate that 10,000 people across England and Wales are currently disputing wills annually, though this represents only the tip of the iceberg as many conflicts resolve privately. Contested wills have increased by a staggering 140% over the past decade, attributed to rising house prices, complex family structures following divorce, and the ongoing cost-of-living crisis making inheritance more financially significant for families.
Table of Contents
How successful is contesting a will?
The likelihood of successfully challenging a will depends entirely on the specific legal grounds and quality of evidence supporting your case. Courts apply strict standards when examining will validity, recognising that overturning someone’s final wishes requires compelling justification.
Professional legal experts report varying success rates depending on the nature of challenges. Lack of testamentary capacity claims succeed in approximately 22-35% of cases where substantial medical evidence demonstrates the deceased lacked mental capacity when making their will. These cases often involve dementia, mental illness, or other conditions affecting decision-making abilities.
Undue influence claims prove more challenging, succeeding in only 10-15% of cases due to the difficulty of proving coercion occurred behind closed doors. However, when clear evidence exists of manipulation or pressure, these cases can achieve favourable outcomes for challengers.
What Are the Main Reasons People Contest Wills?
The four primary grounds for contesting wills in England and Wales each carry different success rates and evidentiary requirements. Understanding these categories helps determine whether pursuing legal action makes financial sense.
Lack of capacity challenges question whether the deceased possessed sufficient mental ability to understand their will’s contents and consequences. Medical records, witness testimony, and expert opinions become essential evidence in these cases.
Undue influence claims allege that someone coerced or manipulated the deceased into changing their will. Recent successful cases include Schrader v Schrader, where a forceful son with a history of violence pressured his 96-year-old mother into leaving him the family home, and Schomberg v Taylor, where persistent telephone pressure reduced an elderly widow to tears before she changed her will.
Legal formality failures occur when wills aren’t properly witnessed or signed according to statutory requirements. These challenges succeed in approximately 30% of cases where clear procedural errors can be demonstrated.
| Contest Grounds | Success Rate | Evidence Required | Time to Resolution | Cost Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lack of Capacity | 22-35% | Medical records, witness testimony | 6-18 months | £25,000-£150,000+ |
| Undue Influence | 10-15% | Circumstantial evidence, witness accounts | 12-24 months | £30,000-£200,000+ |
| Legal Formalities | Around 30% | Documentary proof of errors | 3-12 months | £15,000-£75,000+ |
| Fraud/Forgery | Under 10% | Expert analysis, clear evidence | 12-36 months | £40,000-£250,000+ |
These success rates demonstrate why legal experts emphasise the importance of strong evidence before pursuing will contests. The emotional and financial costs can be devastating if cases fail, particularly when unsuccessful challengers face paying opponents’ legal costs.
Reddit Insights: Real Experiences of Will Contest Challenges
Property Saviour has observed patterns in online discussions that reveal common frustrations families face when considering will contests. One Reddit user described discovering their mother’s property was held as joint tenants rather than tenants in common, automatically transferring her share to their stepfather despite her will specifying otherwise – highlighting the importance of understanding property ownership structures before making inheritance plans.
Another recurring theme involves family members who feel morally entitled to inheritance but lack legal grounds for challenge. Multiple Reddit discussions feature siblings expressing frustration about unequal will distributions, though moral objections rarely constitute valid legal grounds for contest.
These online experiences demonstrate why many families eventually choose alternative solutions rather than pursuing lengthy legal battles that can cost more than the inheritance they’re fighting over.
Real-Life Example: Patricia’s Dilemma in Leeds
Patricia contacted Property Saviour last year facing exactly this situation after her father’s will left his £400,000 house entirely to her stepmother, excluding Patricia and her brother completely. She’d spent months researching will contest options and consulting solicitors, but the legal costs quoted – potentially exceeding £100,000 – made challenging the will financially impractical.
“The solicitors said we might have grounds based on undue influence, but they couldn’t guarantee success and warned the costs could exceed what we’d inherit even if we won,” Patricia explained. “My stepmother refused to negotiate, and the whole situation was destroying our family relationships.”
Rather than risk financial ruin pursuing uncertain legal action, Patricia chose to focus on other assets from her father’s estate. When her stepmother decided to sell inherited property two years later, she approached Property Saviour for a guaranteed purchase that provided certainty without the stress of traditional estate agent sales.
Sometimes accepting unfair situations proves more practical than fighting expensive legal battles with uncertain outcomes. Property Saviour understands these complex family dynamics and offers compassionate solutions when inheritance disputes make property transactions challenging.
Factors That Improve Your Chances of Successfully Contesting a Will
Comprehensive medical evidence documenting mental capacity issues at the time of will creation
Multiple independent witnesses who can testify about undue influence or suspicious circumstances
Professional documentation of procedural errors during will preparation or signing
Clear timeline showing changes in the deceased’s behaviour or relationships before will modifications
Expert legal representation from solicitors specialising in contentious probate matters
Proportionate estate value that justifies potential legal costs and risks involved
Building a strong case requires substantial preparation and often involves costs that can quickly escalate beyond £50,000 even for straightforward challenges.
How Long Does It Take to Contest a Will Successfully?
Will contest timelines vary dramatically based on complexity, cooperation between parties, and court scheduling. Simple cases involving clear procedural errors might resolve within 6-12 months, whilst complex undue influence claims can extend beyond two years.
The vast majority of successful will contests actually resolve through negotiation rather than court proceedings. Approximately half of all contested will cases settle out of court, avoiding the expense and uncertainty of formal litigation.
Only around 2% of will contests proceed to final trial hearings, as most parties prefer negotiated settlements once the strength of evidence becomes clear. This statistic highlights why early legal assessment of your case’s merits proves essential before committing to expensive proceedings.
Alternative Options When Will Contests Seem Unviable
Inheritance Act claims for reasonable provision if you were financially dependent on the deceased
Family mediation to resolve disputes without formal legal proceedings
Negotiated settlements that provide partial satisfaction for all parties involved
Deed of variation arrangements that can modify will terms by mutual agreement
Court applications for maintenance orders if you were being supported by the deceased
These alternatives often achieve better outcomes than adversarial will contests whilst preserving family relationships and reducing legal costs substantially.
Why Most Will Contests Fail Despite Legitimate Grievances?
The legal system places the burden of proof on challengers, requiring clear evidence that meets strict legal standards. Emotional arguments about fairness or moral entitlement carry no weight in probate courts, which focus exclusively on technical legal requirements.
Many families underestimate the evidential challenges involved in proving undue influence or lack of capacity. These cases often rely on circumstantial evidence and witness testimony that may not meet judicial standards for overturning someone’s final wishes.
The costs and risks associated with failed will contests can be financially devastating. Unsuccessful challengers may face paying not only their own legal costs but also those of the winning party, potentially resulting in bills exceeding £200,000 for complex cases.
When Property Disputes Transform Will Contests Into Family Nightmares
Property-related inheritance disputes create a perfect storm of legal complexity that can turn straightforward will contests into years-long family feuds. Joint tenancy arrangements completely bypass will provisions, automatically transferring ownership to surviving joint tenants regardless of what the deceased intended in their final wishes. When multiple properties span different jurisdictions or involve complex trust arrangements, even experienced legal teams struggle to untangle the mess.
The reality is that inherited properties need immediate attention – council tax bills keep arriving, insurance requires renewal, and empty houses attract vandals or squatters. These practical pressures don’t pause whilst families spend months arguing over legal technicalities. Meanwhile, the property’s value may be declining through neglect, and maintenance costs mount up regardless of who eventually inherits.
Why Estate Agents Make Inheritance Disputes Worse?
Traditional estate agents become part of the problem rather than the solution when families are embroiled in will contests. They require unanimous agreement from all potential beneficiaries before marketing properties, which proves impossible when siblings are locked in legal battles. Estate agents also demand properties be presented in pristine condition – a tall order when family members can’t agree on who should pay for repairs or improvements.
Even worse, estate agent sales can collapse at any moment due to buyer financing issues, survey problems, or chain complications. When you’re already facing legal costs that could exceed £100,000, the last thing you need is an uncertain sales process that might fail after months of stress and additional expenses.
Property Saviour’s Practical Solution for Disputed Inheritances
We understand that inheritance disputes involve far more than legal technicalities – they tear apart family relationships, create financial anxiety, and prolong grief when families should be healing together. Our guaranteed purchase service cuts through the complexity by eliminating the need for family consensus about marketing, pricing, or timing.
Unlike estate agents who need perfect cooperation between warring family members, we can work with executors or administrators to provide immediate certainty about property values and completion dates. This removes one major source of conflict whilst allowing families to focus on resolving their differences without the added pressure of property management responsibilities.
Our cash offers provide the financial clarity that legal teams need to negotiate settlements, whilst our rapid completion times mean families can access their inheritance without waiting months for uncertain market outcomes that might never materialise.
Sell with certainty & speed
Property Saviour Price Promise
- The price we’ll offer is the price that you will receive with no hidden deductions.
- Be careful with ‘cash buyers’ who require a valuation needed for a mortgage or bridging loan.
- These valuations or surveys result in delays and price reductions later on.
- We are cash buyers. There are no surveys.
- We always provide proof of funds with every formal offer issued.
We'll Pay £1,500 Towards Your Legal Fees
- No long exclusivity agreement to sign because we are the buyers.
- You are welcome to use your own solicitor.
- If you don’t have one, we can ask our solicitors for recommendations.
- We share our solicitor’s details and issue a Memorandum of Sale.
Sell With Certainty & Speed
- Our approach is transparent and ethical, which is why sellers trust us.
- 100% Discretion guaranteed.
- If you have another buyer, you can put us in a contracts race to see who completes first.
- Complete in 10 days or at a timescale that works for you. You are in control.
